Seth’s Playing Dirty: Check the Facts · Alani Bankhead for Senate
Skip to content

Check the facts

Seth’s playing dirty.

He thinks you’re too dumb to check. Prove him wrong.

What his campaign and his super PACs said, side by side with what’s true.

More videos on our YouTube channel →

What Seth is saying about her

Seth Bodnar himself: his own campaign videos, his own ad, his own interviews.

Seth’s campaign built a whole page about her. Read it yourself (archived copy, in case it disappears).

They said

“Tonight, the Libertarian candidate called Native Americans ‘pets,’ and the candidate on the Democratic ticket, Alani Bankhead, laughed along.”

Seth Bodnar on X, Instagram and Facebook, Oct. 23, 2026

False

The truth

She didn’t laugh at it.

In the organizers’ full livestream of the Billings maternal health forum, Alani isn’t smiling while Kyle Austin says “pet of society.” The smile in Seth’s clip comes seconds later, after Austin finished. She and Austin had been talking before the forum, and a bit of that conversation carried into it. It shouldn’t have, and it had nothing to do with what he’d just said.

Neither of them was listening closely. Alani thought Austin was saying “dependent,” the word his whole answer was built on. Seth spoke next, and his first words were “Can you repeat the question?” He said nothing about the remark until his campaign posted the attack that night, in a clip that crops him out of the frame.

Once she learned what Austin had said, she condemned more than the word. The federal government’s relationship with tribal nations is long and complicated, and whatever word he used, the government has an obligation to do right by them. She doesn’t believe he meant it the way it was taken, but in her words, his comment “was wrong and reflected a serious misunderstanding of tribal sovereignty and the federal government’s relationship with tribal nations.” As she put it, “Friendship doesn’t mean agreement.”

It was about the tenth forum Alani and Austin had done together. Candidates are people. After months of the same questions every day, they get tired, they tune out, and they’re allowed to be human. Two minutes earlier, answering the same question, Alani said “the federal government does not respect brown people” and made restoring tribal health care one of her top priorities.

Watch the full forum, not the clip → (the People’s Food Sovereignty Program’s livestream, starting at Austin’s answer)

They said

Her “sister worked at the church,” with a link to a family member’s LinkedIn page.

Seth Bodnar campaign website, October 2026

Out of bounds

The truth

Now he’s going after her family.

Seth’s campaign is now naming and linking to members of the candidate’s family. If Seth thinks families are fair game in politics, we disagree completely, and we condemn it. Run against her record.

They said

“A pattern of associating with violent extremists and antisemites.”

Seth Bodnar campaign website, October 2026

False

The truth

Their proof is a joke T-shirt from 2016 and one interview.

The interview was with the founder and president of the Montana Veterans Association. Alani built her career putting child predators in prison.

They said

Everything happening to you “is actually happening because you created that.”

Seth Bodnar campaign website, October 2026

Cut off

The truth

They stopped mid-thought.

Her next sentence: “But it’s how you respond to those things that indicates the quality of your life.” (Humble Warrior Ep. 76, 11:21)

They said

“Alani Bankhead belonged to a pro-MAGA mega church that promotes anti-choice and anti-LGBTQ+ views.”

Seth Bodnar campaign video about Alani’s former church

Bodnar campaign video, Sept. 22, 2026. And in his own post on X, Oct. 11: “ties to far-right, anti-choice institutions.”

False

The truth

She stopped going before Trump was ever president.

  • As a teenagerShe started going there.
  • 2011 and 2014Back off and on when the Air Force stationed her in D.C.
  • 2017Her last time there, the year Trump first took office.
  • 2019The Trump visit his ad points to.

Nothing she ever took part in there included that hateful rhetoric. Her record: codify Roe, and protect and respect LGBTQ+ Montanans. Hold every Christian to a former pastor’s views and almost no person of faith could be a Democrat.

Alani, in her own words.

See the receipts

Alani Bankhead is a feed-the-poor Christian, not a storm-the-Capitol Christian. She believes Congress should codify Roe v. Wade, and she said so on camera in June. Seth Bodnar's campaign can't beat her on the issues, so for two weeks it has gone after her faith, calling her old church a "pro-MAGA megachurch" and claiming she's "STILL getting paid by a far-right publisher."

Alani first went to McLean Bible Church in 1999, when she was a teenager and her family attended. She was gone for most of the next decade. When the Air Force sent her back to Washington, D.C., in 2011 and again in 2014, she went back to the church she knew a few times a year, when she needed a place to pray. She never joined a ministry or took part in church activities, and she left D.C. in 2017. The Trump visit Bodnar's campaign points to was in 2019. Roe was overturned in 2022.

The sermons in their video are from Lon Solomon, who led the church from 1980 to 2017. Alani wasn't there for the ones they picked, and she doesn't share those views. Her positions on LGBTQ+ rights are specific and public: enforce civil-rights protections against discrimination and hate, protect access to gender-affirming care, ban so-called conversion therapy, and fund crisis and suicide-prevention services for LGBTQ+ youth. Seth Bodnar's platform doesn't mention LGBTQ+ Montanans at all.

She has talked about her faith publicly before. In a June interview with NonStop Local, she called herself "a Christian at my core" and "non-denominational," and said she hadn't "gone to a church in a number of years." Years of investigating crimes against children changed how she relates to organized religion.

Her answer on Roe in that interview was just as clear. Asked whether Congress should codify it, she said, "I absolutely think we should," and added, "I view religion and government as two very different things." That record is a big part of why NOW PAC endorsed her.

About the book. In 2023, Alani wrote The Least of Us: How Your Imposter Syndrome Points to Your Greatest Power for the Christian women she coached. She paid Genesis Publishing House, a small Christian publisher, a one-time fee to produce it. The publisher doesn't take a share of her sales; its own site says authors keep all of their royalties. Her Senate financial disclosure lists $201 to $1,000 in royalties from her own book. None of the publisher's other books pay her anything.

Attacking someone's faith is reprehensible, and it's worse when the target has spent much of her career protecting kids and survivors of abuse and trafficking. If every Democrat were judged by what a former pastor preached, or by the most conservative positions of their church or denomination, very few people of faith would make it onto the ballot. Seth Bodnar is asking Montanans to judge Alani by a pastor she rarely heard. Judge her by her record instead. It's all public.

Sources: NonStop Local interview, June 23, 2026; Bodnar campaign release, Sept. 18, 2026. Montana Freedom PAC’s TV ad repeats the “anti-LGBTQ church” line.

They said

“Alani Bankhead is still getting paid by a far-right publisher who profits from selling extreme anti-choice books.”

Seth Bodnar campaign video about Alani’s book

His campaign video, Sept. 25, 2026. He said it again on CNN, Sept. 30, and on NewsNation, Oct. 17: “still being paid by a publishing company that profits from selling books calling for abortion to be banned.”

False

The truth

She self-published her own book.

$0of her sales go to the publisher
100%of royalties stay with each author
0ties to far-right groups

She paid a small Christian publisher a one-time fee to produce her book on imposter syndrome. It keeps $0 of her sales and has never printed a Christian nationalist book. The book he’s pointing to came out after she’d already started publishing hers. A publisher printing other authors doesn’t make their views hers.

See the receipts

On CNN on Sept. 30 he said it again: “The person on the Democratic ticket has some long-standing ties to pretty far-right organizations, still being paid by a publishing company that’s profiting from books…” She has no ties to far-right organizations, and they don’t get a dime from her book. Her Senate financial disclosure lists $201 to $1,000 in royalties from her own book.

Sources: Genesis Publishing House; Alani Bankhead Senate financial disclosure, May 27, 2026; CNN, The Arena, Sept. 30, 2026. His super PAC’s mailers repeat it.

They said

Montana deserves a senator who fights for you, “not one who blames you.”

Seth Bodnar campaign ad

His campaign ad, Sept. 29, 2026. His super PAC mailed the same clip.

Twisted

The truth

She was coaching someone making $300,000 a year.

“I know a couple of people who made over $300,000 last year and are broke.” 3:24

Scarcity thinkingAlani’s reframe
Once I hit the next goal, then I’ll feel like I made it.→

“A hallmark of imposter syndrome is that you keep moving the goalpost.”

4:00
I’ll be happy when I make more money.→

“If you don’t learn how to celebrate what you have right now, you are never going to thrive when you arrive.”

3:52
All I can see is what I’m missing.→

“Stop focusing on what you don’t have in the scarcity and refocusing it on what you do have.”

10:02
There isn’t enough money to go around.→The lines they clipped

“Rather than feeling like there isn’t enough… If you live in America, you are in the richest country in the world. You can literally create anything you want.”

27:13
I make six figures and still feel broke.→

“So if you’re poor right now, it’s because you decided you wanted to be poor. …You can actually change it.”

27:27
Two different jobsCoaching: people with plenty who still feel broke. Her Senate run: a system that keeps Montanans from having enough.
See the receipts

“There’s a difference between having the money and not spending it well… and a system that chooses to oppress its individuals and exploit and extract from the Montanans that we serve.”

There's a clip going around, and it's real, but missing important context. It's from a holiday episode of Alani's coaching podcast, a show made for a specific audience: people who already have financial means and can't understand why it never feels like enough.

The example she was working through was a client whose household earned $300,000 a year and was still broke. The episode is about abundance versus scarcity mindset, about people with means who don't manage them well. It was never addressed to, or about, Montanans struggling to afford groceries.

In her own words: "That is very different than what we're combating in terms of affordability. There's a difference between having the money and not spending it well, or wanting more, and a system that chooses to oppress its individuals and exploit and extract from the Montanans that we serve."

Her coaching work helped people who already had abundance change how they thought about it. Her campaign is about dismantling the systems that extract from Montanans who don't. Two different jobs.

Imposter syndrome, what her coaching was about: a persistent feeling that you haven’t really earned where you are. “The thing that you think is your greatest weakness is actually the key to unlocking your greatest power.”

Where she stands on costs: Bringing Down Everyday Costs.

They said

She “won the primary fueled by over $3 million of dark money spending.”

Seth Bodnar at the Indivisible Missoula forum

Seth Bodnar, Indivisible Missoula forum, Sept. 20, 2026. His super PAC’s mailer says it too.

Seth’s money

The truth

Both sides played the primary. Seth’s side bet on her.

GOP PAC ads calling her “Trump-friendly”$901K
GOP PAC ads “attacking” Reilly$1.0M
Seth’s dark-money network, for Alani$2.3M

The Republican PAC (More Jobs, Less Government, a super PAC aligned with Sen. Steve Daines) “supported” Alani by calling her a Trump-friendly, “conservative Democrat,” and “attacked” Reilly as “too liberal,” for universal health care, soft on the border and out to impeach Trump. Those ads were built to boost Reilly with Democrats. Their bet: a Democrat who’d never drop out, splitting the vote against Alme.

Seth’s own dark-money network spent the most, propping Alani up through Progressive Vet PAC. Its treasurer co-hosted a Bodnar fundraiser. Their bet: she’d win the nomination and then drop out for Seth.

She won. She didn’t drop out.

See the receipts

More Jobs, Less Government spent $901,179 on ads supporting Alani in the last two weeks of the primary, casting her as “a Trump-friendly Democrat who’s bullish on immigration enforcement,” and $1,005,876 against Reilly Neill, attacking her as “too liberal,” for universal health care, soft on the border and wanting to impeach Trump. Elections analyst Jacob Rubashkin described one as an ad “intended to boost Reilly Neill in a Democratic primary.” The same PAC also spent $962,124 against Seth Bodnar. Progressive Vet PAC spent $2.3 million for Alani; its money came from Contours, the same dark-money source behind Seth Bodnar’s own super PAC, and its treasurer, Moffie Funk, co-hosted a fundraiser for Bodnar.

Sources: FEC Schedule E filings (More Jobs, Less Government, C00693838; Progressive Vet PAC, C00948521); Montana Free Press, May 26, 2026; Jacob Rubashkin, Inside Elections; Inside Elections, Aug. 7, 2026; MTPR, Sept. 24, 2026. Follow the money.

They said

“Alani Bankhead’s single largest financial supporter is Republican Steve Daines.”

Seth Bodnar on NewsNation, Oct. 17, 2026. He said it on Fox News Live the same day: “Steve Daines and Kurt Alme’s PAC.”

Lie

The truth

Her biggest outside “supporter” was Seth’s own network.

In the primary, the Daines-aligned super PAC spent $901,179 “supporting” Alani with ads built to boost her opponent, and $962,124 against Seth. Progressive Vet PAC spent $2.3 million for Alani, funded by Contours, the same dark-money source behind Seth’s super PAC, and its treasurer co-hosted a Bodnar fundraiser. Alani asked for none of it, and her campaign takes no corporate PAC money.

Receipts: FEC filings for More Jobs, Less Government and Progressive Vet PAC; Fox News Live; NewsNation, posted by his campaign. The full money trail: Follow the Money.

They said

“My Democratic opponent posted a picture of my face on her social media channel with the letters POS.”

Seth Bodnar on the Outlaw Beat podcast

Outlaw Beat podcast, Sept. 9, 2026

Lie

The truth

Alani never posted it.

The post came from the write-in candidate’s account.

His super PAC’s mailers

Paid for by Independent PAC, the super PAC backing Seth Bodnar. The red boxes are theirs, word for word.

They said

“[Alani Bankhead] benefited from Republican spending designed to split the opposition and clear a path for Alme.”

Independent PAC mailer quoting Shannon O’Brien

Independent PAC mailer, late October 2026, reprinting Shannon O’Brien’s Oct. 12 op-ed

Half the story

The truth

The same Republican PAC spent more against Seth.

The Republican money was real, and it was in the May primary. More Jobs, Less Government, a super PAC tied to Steve Daines, spent $901,179 promoting Alani. It also spent $962,124 against Seth. The biggest outside spending for Alani came from Progressive Vet PAC: $2.3 million, funded by Contours, the same dark-money source behind Seth’s super PAC. Alani asked for none of it, and her campaign takes no corporate PAC money.

This four-page mailer is paid for by Independent PAC, the super PAC backing Seth, and it reprints the former party chair’s op-ed as if it came from the party. Alani’s answer to that op-ed: The op-ed I wasn’t allowed to write. Its back page repeats three claims already answered on this page: the church and the publisher, the podcast line about poverty, and “excited about Trump.”

See the receipts

FEC filings for More Jobs, Less Government, Progressive Vet PAC and Independent PAC. The full money trail: Follow the Money.

They said

“…I am going to stay in the race no matter what,” Bankhead told me…even if doing so makes things easier for Republicans.”

Independent PAC mailer quoting The Washington Post
Spliced

The truth

Half of that quote isn’t hers.

Her words“I am going to stay in the race no matter what.”
The reporter’s words, glued on“…even if doing so makes things easier for Republicans.”

What they cut is her reason, from the same article: “I won a primary with 48,000 votes. Seth didn’t. He could have run as a Democrat, and he probably would have won, but he chose not to do that.”

See the receipts

Source: The Washington Post, Early Brief, July 30, 2026. Their TV ad runs the same splice.

They said

Trump’s election was “a really exciting time…”

Independent PAC mailer quoting Alani on Trump’s election
Cut off

The truth

They stopped mid-sentence.

The part they cut

“a really exciting time from a defense standpoint.”

She was talking about defense work. The anonymous blog the mailer cites prints the full line itself.

See the receipts

Source: the July 14, 2026 blog post the mailer cites. The July 14 date is when the blog posted it. She said it earlier.

They said

Planned Parenthood’s PAC endorsed Seth, so Alani can’t be pro-choice.

Independent PAC mailer with Planned Parenthood branding

Independent PAC mailer

Absurd

The truth

Her record is on camera.

National Organization for Women PAC endorses Alani Bankhead

“I absolutely think we should.”

Alani, asked if Congress should codify Roe v. Wade.

The National Organization for Women’s PAC and the National Women’s Political Caucus endorsed her. One group’s endorsement of Seth doesn’t erase her record.

And the reproductive-freedom questionnaire she did fill out is public: Montanans for Choice Take Action’s 2026 voter guide publishes her answers in full, a yes on all 13 of its positions. Kurt Alme didn’t respond. She also answered the ERA Coalition’s Equal Rights Amendment survey, and its Elect Equality guide lists her as a supporter. Seth never responded; the guide lists him as “unknown.”

See the receipts

Planned Parenthood Action Fund had already decided to back Seth before it ever talked to us. Alexandra Acker-Lyons, a member of the Action Fund’s board, called three times in the week before the August 10 withdrawal deadline. She wasn’t calling about a questionnaire. She was calling to get Alani out of the race. No survey was ever sent.

When one of Seth’s supporters asked Alani at a forum about the paperwork behind an endorsement process her staff would have handled, she said she’d answered the questionnaire. The ones she had answered were Montanans for Choice Take Action’s, which endorses no federal candidates but publishes every answer it receives, and NOW PAC’s, which endorsed her. We apologize for the mix-up. Had the Action Fund ever sent her one, she would have answered it too.

Sources: NonStop Local interview, June 23, 2026; NonStop Local, Oct. 2, 2026; Acker-Lyons’s own bio lists her Action Fund board seat; Montanans for Choice Take Action, 2026 Voter Guide at-a-glance (full guide; U.S. Senate questionnaire and at-a-glance comparison).

They said

“Alani Bankhead’s refusal to fill out and submit the Planned Parenthood Action Fund survey… is disqualifying.”

Independent PAC mailer: Nancy Keenan is supporting Seth Bodnar

Quote: NonStop Local, Sept. 25. Mailer: Independent PAC.

Not neutral

The truth

Nancy Keenan was already campaigning for Seth.

The only person quoted by name attacking Alani in that story had already endorsed Seth Bodnar, appears on his super PAC’s mailer (left), and had asked Alani to drop out.

In May 2008, with Keenan as its president, NARAL endorsed Barack Obama over Hillary Clinton mid-primary, and she was the one who announced it. Some habits are hard to break.

See the receipts

Keenan endorsed Bodnar in a Bozeman Daily Chronicle guest column and wrote in an open letter that she had asked Alani to drop out (Montana Free Press, July 31). NBC News later called the 2008 NARAL endorsement a “snub”, and some of NARAL’s own state affiliates distanced themselves from it.

Source: NonStop Local, Sept. 25, 2026.

Who pays for all of this? Seth’s super PACs run on a dark-money chain: Contours → Western Futures Fund → Way Back PAC (a Wyoming shell) → Montana Freedom PAC.

Follow the money →

His super PAC’s TV ads

Montana Freedom PAC, Seth Bodnar’s super PAC.

Montana Freedom PAC ad: Democrat in name onlyFalse

“Not the Democrat she says she is.”

She’s the Democratic nominee, chosen by Montana Democrats and endorsed by the Montana Democratic Party.

Montana Freedom PAC ad: secret FacebookFalse

“A secret Facebook account.”

A privacy alias. After years of undercover work against child predators, she kept her real name off social media on purpose.

Montana Freedom PAC ad: came to Montana three years agoMisleading

“Only lived in Montana three years.”

Every home before Montana, the military picked. Montana is the first place she chose. Seth: about eight years, all in Missoula.

Montana Freedom PAC ad: Yeezy shirtA joke

“Promoted an antisemitic rapper.”

A joke T-shirt from 2016, years before Ye’s antisemitic rants. Her husband wore a “Deez Nuts” shirt the same day.

Montana Freedom PAC ad: met with a January 6 influencerTwisted

“Met with a January 6th MAGA influencer.”

Alani doesn’t condone Sam Redfern’s past behavior, and she respects anyone doing the work to change. He backs I-194 to end dark money and has met leaders across the spectrum. Seth Bodnar invited President Trump to sit down with him.

A voter guide from one of his endorsers

Wild Montana Action Fund endorsed Seth Bodnar in July.

They said

“Her website features general information on her public lands positions, but she has not made meaningful public statements about these positions.”

“Bankhead has not said where she stands on stream access, national monuments, or acquiring new public lands.”

Wild Montana Action Fund’s 2026 Public Lands Voter Guide. It promoted the guide on Instagram (Oct. 19) with a reel made entirely of Seth Bodnar campaign-speech footage.

Public lands, the whole picture: everything the Wild Montana Action Fund guide says about Alani Bankhead and Seth Bodnar, side by side, plus what it left out.
False

The truth

She’s said it since day one.

“No selling of public lands ever. No opening up public lands for exploitation ever.” That’s been her public-lands position since her website launched. Their own guide credits her with defending the Roadless Rule, legalizing corner crossing and making polluters pay, then claims she hasn’t said anything meaningful.

Her positions on stream access, national monuments and buying land for public access are all on her website: defend Montana’s Stream Access Law, defend the Antiquities Act and our monuments, and fully use the Land and Water Conservation Fund to open up locked-up public land. Seth Bodnar’s platform doesn’t mention any of the three. See them side by side at alaniformt.com/guide, or on one page in the whole public-lands picture.

Wild Montana Action Fund isn’t the conservation group Wild Montana.

It’s the group’s political arm, a 501(c)(4) that isn’t required to tell you who funds it, and it bankrolls its own PAC. It endorsed Seth Bodnar in July, before it ever talked with her. In August it emailed her asking her to drop out of the race, telling her its endorsement “is not a reflection on your stance on public lands.” Its guide even treats her support for the bipartisan Public Lands in Public Hands Act as a “but.” That bill stops federal agencies from selling off accessible public land on their own.

Sources: Wild Montana Action Fund voter guide (read Oct. 21, 2026); Alani’s Public Lands position, unchanged since June 2026; Wild Montana, “Introducing Wild Montana Action Fund,” Feb. 26, 2020; FEC C90019993; Montana Free Press, Sept. 2, 2024; Flathead Beacon, July 10, 2026; email from Wild Montana Action Fund to the campaign, Aug. 4, 2026; H.R. 718, Sec. 3.

And his big promise about himself

They said

He’ll negotiate for committee assignments the same way every other senator does.

His answer when asked whether an independent who refuses to caucus can be effective.

Newsweek, July 12, 2026

Not how it works

The truth

Senators don’t negotiate their own seats.

Committee seats come through a party conference. That’s exactly why independents Bernie Sanders and Angus King caucus with Democrats. Without a caucus, there is no third door.

See the receipts

Asked whether an independent who refuses to caucus can be effective, Seth Bodnar said he plans to negotiate for committee assignments the same way every other senator does.

That isn't how the Senate works, and the difference matters enormously for Montana.

Senators don't negotiate for committee seats individually. Each party conference allocates its own slots, Democrats through their Steering Committee, Republicans through their Committee on Committees. At the start of each Congress, the two leaders negotiate an organizing resolution setting the ratios, and the Senate ratifies the conference lists. A senator's committee assignment comes through his conference. There is no third door.

This is precisely why Bernie Sanders and Angus King caucus with Democrats. Both won as independents. Both caucus anyway, because that is the price of a committee seat. The same was true of Joe Lieberman and of Harry Byrd Jr. before him. No senator in modern history has served on committees without caucusing with a party.

So Mr. Bodnar has two options. He can caucus, abandoning the central promise of his campaign. Or he can ask one party to surrender a seat from its own allocation as a favor, which is dependence dressed up as independence.

For Montana, this isn't abstract. Montana has never had influence proportional to its population; it has had influence proportional to its committee seats. Max Baucus chaired Senate Finance. Jon Tester chaired Veterans' Affairs and sat on Appropriations. Agriculture and Interior Appropriations are where farm policy, rural hospital funding, and public lands decisions are actually made. A senator outside both conferences is a senator outside those rooms.

Mr. Bodnar deserves a fair hearing on this. He may believe a party would seat him voluntarily. He may be right that in a narrowly divided chamber, a swing vote carries leverage.

But Montanans are entitled to hear the answer, not simply the assurance. Which committees does he expect to serve on, and through which conference's allocation? Every senator who has faced that question has answered it the same way, by joining a caucus.

Source: Newsweek, July 12, 2026.

He’s betting you won’t check.

Every claim here names its source. Share this page with anyone who got one of those mailers.

Where Alani stands Get involved →